My Insurance Underpaid My Injury Claim. What Can I Do?

Maximizing Compensation After an Underpaid Claim

An insurance company underpaying your claim can leave you frustrated and uncertain about your next steps. At Regan Zambri Long, our Washington, DC bad faith insurance lawyers bring almost 200 years of combined experience to every case we handle. Two of our partners rank among the top 1% of trial lawyers in the nation, and our board-certified trial attorneys have built a reputation for standing up to powerful insurers and securing fair outcomes for shortchanged policyholders.

We know how to challenge undervalued claims, investigate the full scope of your losses, and pursue the compensation you are entitled to under your policy. Our award-winning attorneys have achieved hundreds of successful results, combining legal skill with the resources needed to take on complex disputes.

Has your insurance company underpaid your injury claim? Our legal team has more than 100 5-star Google reviews, and understands how discouraging it feels when an insurer minimizes your losses. Contact Regan Zambri Long today, and one of our experienced attorneys will call you back to explain your options. There is no fee unless we win, and we are available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.

Schedule a free consultation

Contact Us Form

Complete this form and our team will get back to you as soon as possible

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
regan badge
logo 1.png
nbta.png
superlawyers 1 2 1.png
superlawyers 1 1.png
isob 1.png
copy of washingtonian 1.png

Holding Insurers Accountable for Underpayment

Insurance can be confusing and frustrating. Companies don’t always play fair, and this lack of fair dealing can affect your claim. They want to protect their profits, which sometimes means paying you less than you deserve, but you have protection. The law is on your side. Code of the District of Columbia § 31–2231.17 is there to protect you. Insurance companies have strict rules they must follow. These rules are designed to keep them honest and protect you from being taken advantage of in bad faith.

Lying and Misleading

Insurance companies are not allowed to play mind games with you about your policy. They cannot give you wrong information on purpose about what is covered. If there are important details about your coverage or policy limits, they must be upfront and clear with potential policyholders. The insurance company is forbidden from changing your application behind your back or making up reasons to deny your claim in bad faith. Transparency is key, and they must be honest about every aspect of your policy.

Communication Failures

Good communication is critical in insurance claims. Insurance companies must respond to you quickly and clearly about every aspect of your claim. If they decide to deny your claim, they have to explain exactly why. They are required to conduct a thorough investigation of your claim, looking at all the evidence. This means making decisions about your claim in a reasonable amount of time. No more waiting around or getting the runaround.

Settlement Tricks

Insurance companies have a long list of tricks they’re not allowed to use. They cannot trick you into accepting less money than you truly deserve. Pressure tactics are forbidden:

 

  • They can’t push you to take a low-ball offer that barely covers your losses.
  • They are not allowed to create unnecessary obstacles that make getting your payment difficult.
  • The claims process should be straightforward, not long and drawn out in order to wear you down.

Fair Settlement Requirements

When it comes to settling claims, insurance companies have to play fair. If it’s clear that you’re owed money, they must make a genuine effort to settle your claim. This means they should pay you the amount a reasonable person would expect based on the damage or loss. Complete transparency is required. They must explain exactly how they calculated your payment. Honesty about the coverage you’re receiving is non-negotiable. No hidden clauses or surprise limitations.

How Do I Know if My Insurance Claim Was Underpaid?

It’s hard to know on your own if your insurance claim was underpaid – especially if it’s the first time you’ve had to use your car insurance, home insurance, or other type. However, there can be some warning signs that the insurance company potentially undervalued your claim, and as a result, you did not receive the appropriate payment. A few things to look out for include:

  • Known damages were not included in the report. Ask for one if you do not receive an itemized list of what a claim payment includes.
  • A rushed inspection. This can be especially obvious if the damage to your property was extensive. If your accident or claim includes damages that need complicated estimates, it will and should take some time for an adjuster to properly estimate what you will need from your insurance company.
  • Delays in hearing from your insurance company. Delays can happen for a variety of reasons, but most of them benefit your insurance company. For instance, you may become impatient and ready to take any deal they offer.
how to sue an insurance company for bad faith in dc

What Should I Do if My Insurance Company Underpaid My Claim?

In many cases, an insurance company counts on you wanting to leave your accident behind quickly. To really be able to move on, you must be fairly compensated. Whether it be your vehicle, your home, or beyond, insurance is there to protect you and help you put your life back together. If you feel like your insurance company underpaid your claim and acted in bad faith due to denial, you should:
  • Thoroughly review your insurance coverage. You should know exactly what your coverage entitles you to, and what it does not. Policy language can be written in a way that is confusing. Don’t hesitate to ask questions.
  • Understand exactly how your insurance company calculated your claim payment. If you did not receive an itemized list of damages and what they estimated for each item, ask for one. This will help you compare against real quotes from the people contracted to fix your property.
  • Get a second opinion. This might be your first time dealing with an insurance claim payout. So, you are likely not an expert on insurance claims. Seek one out. A private adjuster can give you a second opinion and help you understand if you were underpaid.
  • Hire a lawyer. If you feel your insurance company acted in bad faith by purposefully underpaying your claim, talk to a lawyer today. They can help you understand the specifics of your case. It’s important to note that not every underpayment is the result of bad faith on behalf of your insurance. An experienced lawyer can help consult on the specifics of your case.

Steps to Protect Your Insurance Claim

Protecting yourself starts with careful documentation:

 

  • Take photos of all damage to your property
  • Save every bill and medical record
  • Keep track of repair estimates from different sources
  • Take careful notes when you interact with the insurer
  • Ask for written communication when you can

Keeping detailed records can support your strongest defense. They help prove what happened to you and how much it cost.

Your insurance policy is a contract that protects you. Read it carefully and understand what is or isn’t covered. Don’t accept the first offer from the insurance company. Ask for a detailed breakdown of how they calculated your claim. If something doesn’t make sense, ask questions. You have the right to understand every part of your claim. Your insurer should never deny reasonable requests.

Getting help can make a big difference in your case. A private insurance adjuster can give you a second opinion about your claim. A bad faith insurance attorney can help you understand your rights. They can spot problems you might miss. Crash reconstructionists, claims specialists, and medical experts can help turn a low-ball offer into compensatory damages that reflect your true losses.

Bad faith insurance attorneys at Regan Zambri Long provide legal guidance to clients in Washington, DC.

What Are My Rights if My Insurance Company Underpaid Me?

You have powerful protections when dealing with insurance companies. The law is on your side. Insurers must treat you fairly and honestly. You have the right to get clear information about your policy from the insurer. You deserve honest explanations about claim decisions. The insurance company must thoroughly investigate your claim. You have the right to fair compensation for your losses and can challenge unfair treatment. We encourage you to reach out for help when you believe you’re being treated wrongly. Our bad faith lawyers are here to help.

File a Complaint

If you feel your insurance company is treating you unfairly, you have options. Your first step is to contact Washington, DC’s insurance commissioner. These official watchdogs protect consumers from bad insurance practices.

Prepare your complaint carefully. Collect all claim documents to ensure that the insurance company’s obligations are met. Save every piece of communication with the insurance company. Write a clear, factual description of the problem. Include specific dates and details. Explain exactly how you believe you’ve been treated unfairly.

Resolve Disputes Without Going to Court

Sometimes you can solve insurance conflicts without a lawsuit. You have two main options: mediation and arbitration.

Choose the Right Insurance Policy for You

  • Mediation brings in a neutral third person. This person helps you and the insurance company find a solution. It’s less formal than court. Both sides get to explain their position. The mediator helps find a fair compromise. This method is usually faster and less expensive than a lawsuit.
  • Arbitration requires that an independent arbitrator reviews your entire case. They make a binding decision that both sides must accept. This process is typically quicker and cheaper than going to court. You get a professional review of your claim without a drawn-out legal battle.
Your best option is to pick the right insurance in the first place. Read the entire policy carefully before signing. Look for clear, simple language. Avoid policies with complicated clauses and policy language.
Watch out for red flags when choosing an insurance carrier. You should be suspicious of vague coverage descriptions. Be careful of policies with complicated penalty sections. Unclear claim procedures are another warning sign. Aggressive sales tactics should make you pause. Any pressure to sign quickly is a bad sign.
Ask questions about anything you don’t understand. A good insurance provider will happily review the insurance contract with you before you sign.

Legal Protections

It is your insurer’s duty to follow strict rules. They cannot trick you. Your policy is a promise of protection.
Your insurance company must be honest. They cannot hide important information. They must explain their decisions clearly. They have to treat you fairly.
Specifically, insurance companies cannot:
  • Lie about your coverage
  • Hide important details
  • Change your policy without telling you
  • Deny claims without good reason
  • Drag out your claim
  • Refuse to explain their choices
You have power if this happens. You can fight back. You can file complaints. You can seek legal help. The law protects you from unfair treatment and encourages insurers to act in good faith.

Hire a Washington, DC Bad Faith Insurance Lawyer

After an accident, you may be ready to move on. You have the right to take legal action if you’ve experienced severe injuries and long-lasting property damage. It’s important that you receive the help you need from your insurance company.
If you feel like your claim was underpaid, especially due to emotional distress, contact a lawyer today. Not every underpayment is because of bad faith on the part of your insurance company. Our skilled bad faith claim attorneys are ready to review your insurance company’s conduct.

Why Choose Regan Zambri Long as Your Washington, DC Bad Faith Insurance Lawyer?

At Regan Zambri Long PLLC, our bad faith insurance attorneys have decades of experience handling these cases and battling large insurance companies on behalf of our clients.

 

Since 1997, our firm has achieved dozens of multimillion-dollar settlements and verdicts for clients across the greater DC Metro area, recovering more than a $1 billion in personal injury awards. That success is grounded in a culture of excellence shaped by national recognition and peer respect.

 

All six partners have been named to the Lawdragon 500 Leading Plaintiff Consumer Lawyers list for 2025, while several have earned  Best Lawyers “Lawyer of the Year” honors in areas such as product liability, medical malpractice, and workers’ compensation. Our three senior partners are board-certified by the National Board of Trial Advocacy, and partners Salvatore Zambri, Paul Cornoni, and Patrick Regan have been selected among the Top 100 Super Lawyers in Washington, DC, reflecting the firm’s skill, ethics, and record of results in complex litigation.

 

If you feel that you may have a bad faith lawsuit, contact us today for a free consultation. You will never pay an attorney’s fees unless we win your case.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a Bad Faith Claim?

A bad faith insurance claim is when an insurance company treats you unfairly on purpose. They might try to pay you less money than you should get. This can mean offering you a small amount of money quickly, hoping you’ll accept it without thinking. They’re trying to save money by not paying you what you really need.

How Can I Tell If My Claim Was Underpaid?

Not all low-paid claims constitute bad faith. Look for these warning signs of intentionally underpaid claims:

  • The insurance report is missing some of your damages
  • They rushed through checking your damage
  • You didn’t get a list showing how they calculated your payment
  • They’re taking a long time to respond
  • The money they offer seems too low
  • They won’t explain how they came up with the amount

What Should I Do If I Think My Claim is Too Low?

Insurance companies count on people feeling frustrated and accepting less money than they deserve. Don’t give up hope if you think your insurance claim is unfair. Here are some steps you can take:
  • Read your insurance policy carefully
  • Ask the insurance company to explain their math
  • Get someone else to look at your claim
  • Take pictures of all the damage
  • Keep all your medical bills and repair estimates
  • Talk to a lawyer who knows about insurance claims
  • File a complaint with your Washington, DC’s insurance office

Contact Our Bad Faith Insurance Lawyers Today

Schedule a Free Consultation

Have you or your loved one sustained injuries in Washington DC, Maryland or Virginia? Regan Zambri Long PLLC has the best lawyers in the country to analyze your case and answer the questions you may have.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.