How to Sue an Insurance Company for Bad Faith in DC

Insurance Company Denied Your Claim?

Bad faith by an insurance company can turn a valid claim into a battle for the coverage you’ve already paid for. Regan Zambri Long’s Washington, DC bad faith insurance lawyers bring 200 years of combined experience to these disputes. Our board-certified trial attorneys have been consistently recognized on the Super Lawyers Top 100 in DC list, and two partners are ranked among the top 1% of trial lawyers in the nation.

Our award-winning team investigates denials, timelines, and policy language, documents unfair practices, and builds the evidence needed to pursue full compensation. We work with industry experts and financial professionals to calculate losses, and seek punitive damages when the law allows. From first review to final resolution, we focus on restoring the peace of mind and protection your coverage was meant to provide.

Have you been treated unfairly by your insurer in Washington, DC? If so, we are ready to help. Contact Regan Zambri Long today for a free consultation and one of pour attorneys will call you back. Our legal team has over 100 5 star Google reviews, and we are available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. There is no fee unless we win your case.

Schedule a free consultation

Contact Us Form

Complete this form and our team will get back to you as soon as possible

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
regan badge
logo 1.png
nbta.png
superlawyers 1 2 1.png
superlawyers 1 1.png
isob 1.png
copy of washingtonian 1.png

Understanding Insurance Bad Faith in Washington, DC

pexels pixabay 327540

In Washington, DC, “bad faith” refers to unethical practices by insurance companies when handling claims, such as failing to investigate claims, denying valid claims without reasonable grounds, or delaying payment for unjustifiable reasons.

Bad faith occurs when insurers act unreasonably and contrary to policyholder interests, violating the trust inherent in the initial insurance contract. In Washington, DC, the legal basis for bad faith claims is common law principles and statutory regulations. Seeking professional guidance is key to protecting your rights and recovering compensation. Talk to a bad faith insurance lawyer at Regan Zambri Long for a free case evaluation.

Recognizing Signs of Insurance Bad Faith

If your insurance company is unresponsive or frequently delays responses to your inquiries, it might mean they are not prioritizing your claim. Additionally, if you encounter unexplained delays in the claim handling process, it may suggest that the insurer is trying to avoid paying what you’re entitled to.

 

Another common issue is the denial of claims without a clear, reasonable explanation. If your insurer interprets policy language in an unreasonable or overly restrictive manner, this could also signal bad faith. Insurers are obligated to provide a thorough and honest assessment of claims — and any refusal to do so can be indicative of a much bigger problem. Documenting potential bad faith actions is essential for building your case.

 

It’s important to keep detailed records of all communications with your insurance company, including:

 

  • Dates
  • Times
  • The content of conversations or emails.

Collect any relevant documents, such as claim forms, policy agreements, and correspondence, that may support your claims of bad faith.

 

If you’ve spotted these signs of insurance bad faith, don’t wait. Reach out to Regan Zambri Long to protect your interests and ensure your rights are upheld in the face of potential bad faith practices.

What Are My Rights as a Policyholder in Washington, DC?

washington dc bad faith attorneys

As a policyholder in Washington, DC, you have specific rights designed to protect you from unfair treatment by insurance companies. Insurers have a legal duty to act in good faith, which includes:

 

  • Promptly processing claims
  • Providing clear reasons for any denial
  • Communicating effectively with you throughout the claims process

They are also required to conduct thorough investigations of claims and pay out valid claims in a timely manner.

Under DC insurance laws, policyholders are entitled to protections that prevent insurers from engaging in deceptive practices. These laws establish your right to a fair assessment of your claim and the obligation of your insurer to adhere to the terms of your policy.

Understanding these rights helps empower you to advocate for yourself effectively when dealing with potential bad faith practices. Additionally, it’s important to have a clear grasp of your policy terms. Knowing what is covered and any exclusions that may apply will help you throughout the claims process, especially when dealing with first-party claims — those you file against your own insurance policy.

 

Familiarity with your rights and your policy can be the key to a successful claim resolution. Taking the time to understand your rights can make all the difference in ensuring you receive the coverage you’ve paid for.

Contact Our DC Bad Faith Insurance Attorneys Today

Steps to Take When Facing Bad Faith Insurance Practices in DC

If you believe your insurance company is engaging in bad faith practices, taking the right steps can help protect your rights — and strengthen your case.

Pre-Lawsuit Steps

Before filing, insurers must receive a 30-day written notice detailing specific allegations via certified mail. A comprehensive demand letter outlining requested relief and supporting evidence is also required. Claims exceeding $25,000 must go through mandatory mediation.

  • Document all communications with your insurer. Keep detailed records of phone calls, emails, and any correspondence related to your claim. Take note of dates, times, and the names of representatives you speak with; this information will be valuable if you need to escalate your complaint.
  • File a formal complaint with the D.C. Department of Insurance, Securities and Banking. This agency oversees insurance practices in the district and can investigate complaints against insurers. By filing a complaint, you not only document your concerns but also signal to the insurer that you are serious about addressing the issue.
  • Gather evidence to support your case. Compile all relevant documentation, including your insurance policy, claim forms, photographs, and any communication that demonstrates the insurer’s bad faith practices. This evidence will be vital if you decide to pursue legal action or negotiate a settlement.

The Legal Process of Suing an Insurance Company in DC

The legal process of suing an insurance company in Washington, DC is complex and requires filing within three years of the company’s bad faith actions. Potential damages include compensatory, punitive, and remedies. Litigation can involve discovery, evidence exchange, depositions, negotiation, mediation, or even a trial if a settlement cannot be reached.

Court Selection and Initial Steps

The DC Superior Court Civil Division handles insurance bad faith claims under $500,000, offering a more direct path to resolution. Cases exceeding $500,000 typically move to the Federal District Court, provided they meet diversity jurisdiction requirements. There will be fees for initial filing in Superior Court and  in Federal Court. Additional expenses include service of process, motion filings, and transcript fees (per page).

Documentation and Filing Requirements

A successful bad faith lawsuit starts with a properly structured complaint containing detailed factual allegations and specific causes of action. Essential documentation includes:

 

  • The insurance policy
  • Complete claim history
  • All correspondence
  • Relevant expert reports

The court requires a civil cover sheet, summons, and notice of the initial scheduling conference alongside these materials.

 

DC law provides several methods for serving defendants: personal service, certified mail, or publication when approved by the court. Plaintiffs have 60 days to complete service, with extensions available for justified delays. International service follows additional protocols depending on the destination country.

Damages

DC courts recognize both compensatory and punitive damages in bad faith cases. Compensatory damages cover the original claim amount plus consequential losses, while punitive damages can reach up to five times the compensatory amount with clear and convincing evidence. Interest accrues annually pre-judgment, with post-judgment rates set at the Federal Reserve rate plus a rate determined.

Legal Fee Recovery

Under DC Code § 28-3905, successful plaintiffs can recover attorney fees calculated using the lodestar method, which multiplies reasonable hourly rates by hours worked. Most attorneys handle bad faith insurance cases on a contingency fee basis, meaning you pay no upfront costs and fees are only collected if your case succeeds. The DC Bar Association provides rate guidelines, and courts may apply multipliers for exceptional results.

 

If your insurance company has acted in bad faith call the attorneys at Regan Zambri Long.  They have extensive experience holding insurance companies accountable and securing fair compensation for their clients. Contact us today for a free consultation to discuss your case and understand your options for pursuing justice.

Why Choose Regan Zambri Long as Your Washington, DC Bad Faith Insurance Lawyer?

When pursuing a bad faith insurance claim in DC, an experienced attorney can construct a detailed case built on documentation, expert testimony, and proven legal strategies that can withstand challenges from powerful insurance companies and their extensive legal teams. Building a thorough case becomes particularly important when dealing with multiple parties, intricate legal issues, significant damages, and the statute of limitations.

 

At Regan Zambri Long, we have recovered more than $1 billion in verdicts and settlements for clients in Washington, DC, earning a reputation as one of the region’s leading personal injury law firms. All six partners are included in the 2025 Lawdragon 500 Leading Plaintiff Consumer Lawyers list, reflecting our national standing in complex litigation. Several of our attorneys have also been recognized by Best Lawyers, with Patrick Regan, Salvatore Zambri, and Paul Cornoni each named Lawyer of the Year in their respective fields.

 

Our leadership includes several past presidents of the American Board of Trial Advocates’ DC Chapter, and the District of Columbia Trial Lawyers Association, and Fellows of the American College of Trial Lawyers, the International Academy of Trial Lawyers, and the International Society of Barristers. Each of these invitation-only organizations admits only attorneys who exemplify the highest standards of trial advocacy, integrity, and professionalism.

 

Don’t face the insurance company alone. Our expertise as DC personal injury lawyers can make a difference in achieving a favorable outcome.

Schedule a Free Consultation

Have you or your loved one sustained injuries in Washington DC, Maryland or Virginia? Regan Zambri Long PLLC has the best lawyers in the country to analyze your case and answer the questions you may have.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.