What Is the Difference Between a Criminal and Civil Case?

Every day in Washington, DC, people find themselves facing situations that trigger both criminal and civil legal proceedings. The difference between them comes down to purpose: criminal cases punish wrongdoing and protect the public, while civil cases compensate victims for their losses. If a drunk driver hits and injures you, for example, they face criminal charges, and you can sue them for compensation for your injuries.

At Regan Zambri Long, we’ve spent over 30 years representing injury victims in civil cases throughout Washington, DC, Maryland, and Virginia. Our personal injury attorneys understand how criminal proceedings can affect your civil case, and how to maximize your compensation regardless of the criminal outcome.

The key to understanding criminal vs civil law lies in recognizing that these two systems serve different purposes and follow different rules. Criminal law protects society as a whole, while civil law resolves disputes between private parties. This fundamental distinction affects everything from who files the case to what evidence is required to win.

Schedule a free consultation

Contact Us Form

Complete this form and our team will get back to you as soon as possible

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
regan badge
logo 1.png
nbta.png
superlawyers 1 2 1.png
superlawyers 1 1.png
isob 1.png
copy of washingtonian 1.png

The Difference Between Criminal and Civil Law

The same incident can produce two separate legal cases because two distinct court systems may address your situation. Knowing what each system covers explains why identical facts can lead to different outcomes in different courts.

What Is Criminal Law?

Criminal law represents society’s rules about behavior that threatens public safety and order. When someone commits a crime, they’re considered to have wronged society as a whole, not just the immediate victim. This is why criminal cases are filed by government prosecutors—either district attorneys at the state level or federal prosecutors for federal crimes.

The primary purpose of criminal law is to protect the public through punishment and deterrence. When someone is convicted of drunk driving, for example, they face jail time, fines, and license suspension not just to punish them, but to deter others from similar behavior. Criminal law covers offenses like DUI, assault, theft, murder, and countless other acts that society considers serious enough to require prosecution.

Criminal cases carry the potential for imprisonment, which is why they require the highest burden of proof in our legal system. The government must prove every element of a crime beyond a reasonable doubt before someone can be convicted and lose their freedom. This means jurors must be firmly convinced of guilt, the evidence must be so strong that they have no reasonable doubt remaining.

What Is Civil Law ?

Civil law handles disputes between private parties, whether they’re individuals, businesses, or organizations. When someone files a civil case, they’re seeking compensation for harm they’ve suffered, not punishment for the person who caused it. This is why civil cases are filed by private plaintiffs against defendants, rather than by government prosecutors.

The primary purpose of civil law is to restore injured parties through monetary compensation. If that same drunk driver damages your car and injures you, a civil lawsuit would focus on recovering money for your medical bills, lost wages, car repairs, and pain and suffering. Civil law covers personal injury claims, contract disputes, property damage, and many other situations where one party believes another has caused them harm.

This is where experienced personal injury attorneys become essential. While criminal prosecutors handle the state’s case, Regan Zambri Long focuses exclusively on maximizing your civil recovery, medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and future damages that you typically can’t recover in criminal court.

Civil cases don’t involve jail time, so they require a lower burden of proof than criminal cases. Plaintiffs only need to prove their case by a preponderance of the evidence, meaning they must show it’s more likely than not that the defendant caused their harm, essentially tipping the scales of evidence in their favor.
What are examples of Civil Rights Violations?

How Criminal and Civil Cases Work

The procedures in criminal and civil cases explain why these two systems can reach different conclusions about the same incident. Each system has its own timeline, evidence rules, and decision-making process.

The Criminal Legal System

Criminal cases begin when law enforcement investigates alleged crimes and gathers evidence. If prosecutors believe they have sufficient evidence, they file formal charges and the defendant is arrested or summoned to court. The arraignment represents the defendant’s first court appearance, where they learn about the charges and enter a plea of guilty, not guilty, or no contest.

During the pre-trial phase, both sides engage in discovery, sharing evidence and witness information. Defense attorneys file motions to suppress evidence or dismiss charges, while prosecutors prepare their case. Many criminal cases end during this phase through plea negotiations, where defendants agree to plead guilty to reduced charges in exchange for lighter sentences.

If the case goes to trial, prosecutors must prove every element of the crime beyond a reasonable doubt. They present evidence and witness testimony to convince the jury that the defendant committed the alleged crime. Defense attorneys challenge the prosecution’s evidence and may present their own witnesses or evidence to create a reasonable doubt.

The Civil Case Process

Civil cases begin when plaintiffs file complaints in court, formally accusing defendants of causing them harm. Defendants must respond within a specified time period, either admitting or denying the allegations. This initial pleading phase establishes the basic claims and defenses for trial.

Discovery is usually the longest part of a civil case. Both sides gather evidence through document requests, depositions, and expert witness reports. Unlike criminal cases, civil discovery is much more extensive, allowing both sides to explore any information that might be relevant to their claims or defenses.

Throughout the case, parties engage in settlement negotiations, often with the help of mediators or arbitrators. Many civil cases settle before trial, as both sides recognize the costs and uncertainties of going to court. Insurance companies, in particular, often prefer settling personal injury cases rather than risking large jury verdicts.

Civil cases that do go to trial follow a similar format to criminal trials, but with different evidence standards and jury instructions. Plaintiffs must prove their case by a preponderance of the evidence, meaning they must show it’s more likely than not that defendants caused their harm.

Personal Injury Lawyers from Regan Zambri Long

Criminal vs Civil Case Outcomes

The results of criminal and civil cases differ dramatically because these two systems serve different purposes and impose different types of consequences on defendants. This is why the same incident can result in acquittal in criminal court but liability in civil court—the evidence might not be strong enough to eliminate reasonable doubt (required for criminal conviction) but can still tip the scales in favor of the plaintiff (sufficient for civil liability).

Criminal Case Results

If a defendant is found guilty, they face:
  • Incarceration or probation: Length depends on crime severity, prior criminal record, and state sentencing guidelines
  • Fines and restitution: Fines punish the crime; restitution compensates victims (though often limited and doesn’t fully cover all damages)
  • Permanent criminal record: Can affect employment, professional licensing, housing, and voting rights—often lasting far longer than any sentence

Civil Case Results

Civil cases aim to restore plaintiffs through monetary compensation:

  • Economic damages: Medical bills, lost wages, and property damage
  • Non-economic damages: Pain and suffering, emotional distress, and loss of enjoyment of life
  • Punitive damages: Rare awards for particularly egregious conduct, requiring evidence of intentional wrongdoing or extreme recklessness
Collecting a civil judgment can pose challenges, especially if the defendants lack sufficient assets or insurance coverage. Plaintiffs may need to garnish the defendant’s wages, seize assets, or negotiate payment plans to actually recover their owed damages.

When Criminal and Civil Cases Overlap

Criminal and civil cases can arise from the same incident because our legal system allows both types of proceedings simultaneously. These situations are more common than many realize and can significantly impact both defendants and victims.

Examples of Criminal and Civil Cases

The same incident can trigger both criminal and civil proceedings in several scenarios:
  • Motor vehicle accidents: When drunk drivers cause accidents, they face criminal charges for DUI while victims can file civil lawsuits for personal injury and property damage. The criminal case punishes the drunk driver and protects public safety, while the civil case compensates victims for their losses.
  • Assault and battery: Criminal prosecution addresses the defendant’s violation of laws against violence, while civil lawsuits seek compensation for medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering. Even if a defendant is acquitted in criminal court, they can still be found liable in civil court because of the different evidence standards.
  • Workplace incidents: Safety violations can trigger OSHA investigations and fines, criminal charges for egregious violations, and civil claims through workers’ compensation or personal injury lawsuits.
  • Medical malpractice: While most cases are purely civil matters, extreme cases involving intentional harm or gross negligence can result in criminal charges alongside civil liability.
  • Business fraud: White-collar crimes like securities fraud or embezzlement often result in both criminal prosecutions and civil lawsuits seeking to recover stolen funds or damages.

Coordinating Civil and Criminal Cases

When both criminal and civil cases arise from the same incident, coordination becomes essential. Evidence from one case can potentially be used in the other, and witnesses need to tell the same story in both proceedings. Defendants may be more willing to settle civil cases to avoid the publicity of dual proceedings, while criminal outcomes can influence civil settlement negotiations.<

Common Questions About Criminal vs Civil Cases

Can I file a civil lawsuit even if the criminal case hasn’t concluded?

Yes. Civil and criminal cases can proceed simultaneously, though your attorney may recommend strategic timing based on your specific situation.

If someone is found not guilty in criminal court, can I still sue them?

Yes. The lower burden of proof in civil cases means you can still win compensation even after a criminal acquittal. The evidence that wasn’t strong enough to eliminate reasonable doubt in criminal court may still be sufficient to tip the scales in your favor in civil court.

Do I need the same attorney for both cases?

No. The government prosecutor handles the criminal case, while your personal injury attorney handles your civil case for compensation. These are separate proceedings with different goals, the criminal case punishes the wrongdoer, while your civil case gets you compensated for your injuries.

Why Choose Regan Zambri Long For Your Civil Case

At Regan Zambri Long, we bring over 30 years of experience handling personal injury and civil litigation cases throughout Washington DC, Maryland, and Virginia. Our attorneys understand how criminal proceedings can impact your civil case and work to maximize your compensation while criminal cases unfold.
We have recovered over $1 billion in compensation for injury victims. We focus exclusively on civil claims involving negligence and personal injuries, pursuing the full compensation you deserve for medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and future damages. We know the local courts, judges, and procedures that can affect your case outcome.
If you’ve been injured due to someone else’s negligence and are seeking civil compensation, our personal injury attorneys can guide you through the process and help you achieve the best possible outcome. Contact us today to schedule a free consultation.

Contact Our Experienced Attorneys Today

Schedule a Free Consultation

Have you or your loved one sustained injuries in Washington DC, Maryland or Virginia? Regan Zambri Long PLLC has the best lawyers in the country to analyze your case and answer the questions you may have.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.